Skip to main content

Main menu

  • About Us
    • Leadership
    • Our Team
    • Vision, Mission and Values
    • Health and Economic Impact
    • Research Impact Video
    • Strategic Plan
  • Our Research
    • Research Focus
      • Brain Health
      • Cancer
      • Digital Health and Artificial Intelligence
      • Heart Health
      • Healthy Aging and Mobility
      • Immune System
      • Injury and Rehabilitation
      • Lung Health
      • Mental Health and Substance Use
    • Research Centres and Programs
      • BC Centre on Substance Use
      • Centre for Aging SMART
      • Centre for Cardiovascular Innovation
      • Centre for Clinical Epidemiology and Evaluation
      • Centre for Lung Health
      • Djavad Mowafaghian Centre for Brain Health
      • Immunity and Infection Research Centre
      • International Collaboration On Repair Discoveries
      • M. H. Mohseni Institute of Urologic Sciences
      • Ovarian Cancer Research Centre
      • Community Research Program
      • Emergency Medicine Research Program
      • Hematology Research Program
      • Skin Research Program
      • Other Research Focus Areas
    • News and Stories
    • Researcher Directory
    • Events and Workshops
  • Research Services
    • New to VCHRI
      • Working at VCHRI
      • Regulations and Training
      • Membership with VCHRI
      • Learning and Development
    • Starting Your Project
      • Research Facilitation
      • Awards and Funding
      • Grant Management
      • Operational Approval
      • CST Cerner
    • Developing Your Project
      • Clinical Trials Administration
      • Clinical Research Unit
      • Research Privacy
      • Financial Policies and Procedures
    • Additional Support
      • Indigenous Health Research Unit
      • VCH-VCHRI AI Hub
      • Communications and Media Relations
      • Study Recruitment Support
      • Innovation and Industry Partnership
    • Internal Awards
    • Clinical Research
    • Indigenous Research
  • Participate in Research
    • Reasons to Participate
    • Participant Stories
    • Find a Study
    • Recruitment Support

User menu

  • Log in

Breadcrumb

  1. Home
  2. Our Research
  3. News and Stories
  4. Protecting patients and the planet from unnecessary tests

Protecting patients and the planet from unnecessary tests

Stories Jan 12, 2024 3 minutes

Research into the triple bottom line of sustainable health care uncovers new ways to reduce costs to people, health care and the environment.

Climate change is a universal problem that impacts both environmental and human health. In response, Vancouver Coastal Health Research Institute researcher Dr. Andrea MacNeill and Dr. Karina Spoyalo are looking at how sustainable health care can contribute to reducing greenhouse gas emissions and mitigate the harms associated with climate change.

Andrea MacNeill is a clinical associate professor at the University of British Columbia (UBC) and a surgical oncologist at Vancouver General Hospital (VGH) and BC Cancer. She is the founder and principal investigator of the UBC Planetary Healthcare Lab and regional medical director for planetary health with Vancouver Coastal Health.

“One of the biggest takeaways in the emerging field of sustainable health care is that what is good for the environment is good for patients,” states Spoyalo. “The sum of the parts becomes greater in the end.”

“Globally, health care contributes 5.2 per cent of greenhouse gas emissions. In Canada, pollution from the health care industry accounts for 23,000 disability-adjusted life-years lost annually.”

In her 2021 research paper, MacNeill defines a framework for constructing the emerging field of environmentally sustainable health systems. She describes it as reducing the demand for health services through preventive measures; avoiding unnecessary investigations and treatments; and decarbonizing processes of care.

“The health sector is uniquely positioned to lead global climate action,” states MacNeill. “Rethinking health care through a holistic lens of sustainability will help realise the Canadian federal government’s goals of achieving net zero emissions by 2050 and developing low-carbon, sustainable and resilient health systems.”

A call for reducing unnecessary blood work

MacNeill and Spoyalo’s recent study, published in BMJ Open Quality, applies a triple bottom line framework that estimates the burden of unnecessary blood work on acute care surgical patients. The triple bottom line approach is used to assess treatment outcomes in terms of impacts to patient health, health care expenditures and the environment.

The research team looked at the hospital records of 304 patients admitted to hospital with a handful of acute yet uncomplicated conditions. Of these, 83 patients were randomly selected for an in-depth chart review.

Dr. Karina Spoyalo is a general surgery resident at VGH and member of the UBC Planetary Healthcare Lab.

The team compared the blood work requested in the studied cohort against recommendations for appropriate investigations that were agreed upon by 17 general surgeons at VGH. They found that 76 per cent of the patients reviewed in-depth underwent unnecessary blood work. 

Researchers found that the unnecessary blood work ordered contributed to a mean 1.84 additional requisitioned blood draws, 16.5 blood tests — individual tests that pathologists conduct on blood draws — and 18 millilitres of blood per patient. This resulted in $5,235 of additional costs from the health care system and an extra 61 kilograms of greenhouse gas emissions known to contribute to climate change. 

“Similar to the campaign to stop the misuse of antibiotic medications, we need to educate health care providers about why appropriate testing is better than more testing.”

“Ordering tests reflexively can result in false positive or negative results that can lead to unnecessary care that drains health care resources, taking them away from other patients in critical need,” states Spoyalo. “It can also lead to avoidable anxiety and potential negative side effects for patients.”

However, getting to the stage of promoting smarter testing first requires a body of evidence to back up triple bottom line recommendations, adds Spoyalo. “You cannot fix or improve something that you do not fully understand.” 

“We are now learning a lot more about the potentially harmful effects of unnecessary testing, such as blood work.”

“What we need now is thoughtful ordering of laboratory investigations,” says Spoyalo. “This could include unbundling blood tests to avoid wastage, as well as educating physicians and patients about the costs and human and environmental harms associated with unnecessary lab work.”

 

Researchers

Andrea MacNeill

Related Articles

Air filter rebates for people in B.C. with asthma

Ask an expert: What can I do to improve health care sustainability?

One in five new cases of childhood asthma in Canada are caused by traffic pollution

Share:

  • Facebook
  • Linkedin
  • Twitter
  • Email

Get the latest research headlines in your inbox

Subscribe

Recent News and Stories

Type
Announcement

Celebrating the life and distinguished career of Dr. Marcel Dvorak

May 14, 2025
Type
Stories

More equitable representation needed in Parkinson’s research

May 9, 2025 parkinsons, patient engagement, women
Type
Stories

Gamified stroke recovery improves arm function

May 8, 2025 stroke, rehabilitation
See more news

Get updates!

Join our newsletter mailing list to stay up to date on features and releases.

Subscribe

Quick Links

  • News and Stories
  • Careers
  • Events
  • Media Enquiries

Follow Us

  • LinkedIn
  • X
  • YouTube

© 2025 VCHRI. All rights reserved.

  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy